|ORIGINAL ARTICLE - COMPARATIVE STUDY
|Year : 2020 | Volume
| Issue : 2 | Page : 292-296
Randomized clinical trial comparing three local hemostatic agents for dental extractions in patients under chronic anticoagulant therapy - A comparative study
Sebastian Ariel Puia, Ezequiel Matias Hilber, Matias Garcia-Blanco
Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, School of Dentistry, University of Buenos Aires, Buenos Aires, Argentina
|Date of Submission||13-Jun-2020|
|Date of Acceptance||20-Aug-2020|
|Date of Web Publication||23-Dec-2020|
Dr. Matias Garcia-Blanco
Av De Los Incas 3295 37 (CP 1426), Buenos Aires
Introduction: Oral anticoagulants are widely used worldwide for many systemic diseases. Recent oral surgical protocols suggest that therapeutic levels of the anticoagulant drug should be maintained for simple dental extractions because bleeding complications could be managed with proper local hemostasis. The aim of the present study was to compare bleeding complication of three different local hemostatic agents for dental extractions without interrupting drug administration in patients undergoing oral Vitamin K antagonist chronic anticoagulant therapy. Material and Methods: Randomized control trial of three hemostatic agents for dental extractions, in patients under oral anticoagulant therapy without drug interruption. The present study included 240 patients with international normalized ratio between 1.5 and 3.5. Patients took their anticoagulation drug normally. A single surgeon performed calibrated simple dental extractions and applied a plug of bismuth subgallate (BS), fibrin tissue adhesive (FTA) or microfibrillar collagen (MC), assigned randomly. Statistical analysis of bleeding between the groups was performed using the Chi-square test. Results: There was no hemorrhagic complication in the BS group, and only one in the FTA group. However, in the MC group, 10 patients (12.5%) suffered postoperative bleeding. Data analysis showed statistical differences between the MC group and the other two groups (P < 0.05). Discussion: BS and FTA showed similar clinical effectiveness and were more effective than MC for the control of postoperative bleeding in oral anticoagulated patients.
Keywords: Bismuth subgallate, chronic anticoagulant therapy, dental extraction, fibrin tissue adhesive, hemorrhage, hemostatic agent, microfibrillar collagen
|How to cite this article:|
Puia SA, Hilber EM, Garcia-Blanco M. Randomized clinical trial comparing three local hemostatic agents for dental extractions in patients under chronic anticoagulant therapy - A comparative study. Ann Maxillofac Surg 2020;10:292-6
|How to cite this URL:|
Puia SA, Hilber EM, Garcia-Blanco M. Randomized clinical trial comparing three local hemostatic agents for dental extractions in patients under chronic anticoagulant therapy - A comparative study. Ann Maxillofac Surg [serial online] 2020 [cited 2021 Mar 1];10:292-6. Available from: https://www.amsjournal.com/text.asp?2020/10/2/292/304402
| Introduction|| |
Secondary bleeding after dental surgeries can lead to emergency presentation, occurring most often in anticoagulated patients., Vitamin K antagonists are oral anticoagulant agents derived from 4-hydroxy-coumarin that reduce plasma concentration of coagulation factors II, VII, IX a and X. These drugs reduce the risk of thromboembolism, but increase the risk of hemorrhage. They are used on patients with deep-vein thrombosis, pulmonary embolism, mitral valve prolapse with regurgitation, atrial fibrillation, rheumatic heart disease, or mechanical cardiac valve prosthesis, as well as after cerebrovascular occlusions or myocardial infarction. Dental extraction is often performed on patients who take different oral anticoagulant treatments. Conventionally, treatment protocol included discontinuation of the oral anticoagulant drug for several days immediately before the surgery, bridging it with heparin., The management of dental extraction in patients receiving oral anticoagulation has changed in recent years because of the risk: benefit ratio of a postextraction hemorrhage or a potentially deadly thromboembolic episode. Therefore, the current trend for patients who take oral anticoagulants and need minor oral surgery is to maintain the anticoagulation therapy and improve the hemostatic process by using local hemostatic agents., Several local hemostatic agents have been used after tooth extractions in patients under sustained anticoagulation therapy, such as tranexamic acid, fibrin tissue adhesive (FTA), microfibrillar collagen (MC), or gelatin sponge., However, no data exist in the literature on the clinical use of bismuth subgallate (BS) as a local anticoagulant agent in dental extractions.
The aim of the present study was to perform a clinical evaluation of the effectiveness of three hemostatic agents–BS, FTA, and MC in dental extractions in patients undergoing chronic oral anticoagulant therapy, without drug interruption.
| Patients and Methods|| |
Patients under chronic oral Vitamin K antagonist anticoagulant therapy that presented to the Oral Surgery Department in Buenos Aires, Argentina, from March 2014 to December 2018, were included in the study. The study design was approved by the Ethical Committee of the University of Buenos Aires (Research Ethics Committee No. 006 CD48607), in accordance with its ethical guidelines of declaration of Helsinki. Written informed consent was obtained before the study. The inclusion criteria for this study were: age >18 years, patients under chronic oral Vitamin K antagonist treatment, simple dental extractions, and signature of informed consent form. The exclusion criteria were: medical conditions contraindicating surgery (such as uncontrolled systemic diseases), patients under chronic new oral anticoagulant drugs (such as rivaroxaban, apixaban, or endoxaban), patients unable to receive any standard medications, third molar surgeries, patients with an international normalized ratio (INR) value lower than 1.5 or higher than 3.5, patients with hepatic disease or taking drugs able to affect hepatic functions.
A clinical research comparing three treatment groups, with randomly allocation was designed. The patients underwent clinical and radiographic examination and their systemic coagulant situation was evaluated. The etiologies of extractions were advanced dental caries or periodontal disease. None of the patients interrupted their systemic anticoagulant therapy. INR values at the time of surgery were recorded. Prophylactic antibiotic treatment was applied if patients were at risk of bacterial endocarditis according to the standardized guideline of the American Heart Association. Patients were randomly allocated to one of three groups (n = 80) by using a random numbers function in Microsoft Office Excel software, and their identifications kept inside envelopes numbered according to the order in which they presented for surgery. Group 1 was treated with BS [Figure 1], Group 2 with FTA [Figure 2], and Group 3 with MC [Figure 3]. A single professional, trained in dealing with patients with bleeding disorders, performed the extractions. Surgeries consisted of applying local anesthesia (4% articaine chlorhydrate and 1:100,000 adrenaline), intracrevicular incision, gentle dissection of the gingiva, no surgical flap, no ostectomy, using elevator and forceps. After extraction, wound toilette was performed, and the local hemostatic plug was placed in the socket. BS powder was mixed with physiological solution in a ratio of 0.5 g of BS every 0.3 ml of liquid, making a paste to completely filling the socket. FTA was placed with a mixer disposable syringe; applied from the apical to the coronal portion of the socket completely filling it. MC pellets were embedded in blood, and packed in the socket. Finally, the wound was sutured. All patients received the same postoperative indications, which included cold soft diet for 48 h, intermittent local application of cold, and no use of mouth rinses, aspirin or nonsteroid anti-inflammatory drugs. Paracetamol was administered for pain relief. Patients were instructed to contact the service immediately if a hemorrhagic episode developed. Patients were checked 30 min after the surgery to evaluate the presence of immediate hemorrhages, and a compressive pack was applied for 4 h. A different professional, who was not involved in the surgery, checked patients during the whole week, evaluating the presence of mediate hemorrhages. At 7th day after the surgery, sutures were removed.
|Figure 1: Bismuth subgallate. (a) Presurgical; (b) Bismuth subgallate; (c) Simple suture; (d) 7 days postoperative|
Click here to view
|Figure 2: Fibrin tissue adhesive. (a) Presurgical; (b) Surgical lodge; (c) Fibrin tissue adhesive and a simple suture; (d) 7 days postoperative|
Click here to view
|Figure 3: Microfibrillar collagen. (a) Presurgical; (b) Microfibrillar collagen; (c) A simple suture; (d) 7 days postoperative|
Click here to view
A previously established standard protocol was used to compile the following data for all patients: age, gender, reason for anticoagulant therapy (secondary variables), INR, Quick test (confounder variables), immediate hemorrhage, and mediate hemorrhage (primary variables). There was no dropout. Statistical analysis included descriptive statistics of numerical variables, including arithmetic mean, standard deviation, minimum and maximum (range). INR and quick values were compared between groups with Kruskal–Wallis test. The association between the categorical variables was examined using the Pearson's Chi-square. Statistical analysis was performed with the SPSS software (SPSS version 12.0, Chicago, IL, USA). The level of statistical significance was set at 0.05. The sample size was estimated with the data analysis of the first 60 patients.
| Results|| |
Two hundred and sixty-seven extractions were performed on 240 patients (94 males and 146 females) aged 36–94 years (mean 60.5 ± 14.5 years). The most frequent reason for being under anticoagulant therapy was aortic valve replacement in all groups [Table 1]. Mean INR value was 2.62, and mean quick test value was 26.80%. No patient from any of the three groups (BS, FTA or MC) experienced immediate postoperative bleeding, but 11 patients suffered mediate postoperative bleeding complications [Table 2].
In group BS (mean INR 2.56 ± 0.6, mean quick test 27.5% ± 9.7), no bleeding complication was observed during the whole week (0%).
In group FTA (mean INR 2.71 ± 0.5, mean quick test 25.1% ±7.3), a single postoperative bleeding complication was observed (1.25%) 24 h after 4 teeth were extracted in a 62-year-old man (INR 3.02) who was taking acenocoumarol to treat a mitral and aortic valve replacement. Hemorrhage was controlled through clinical maneuvers which consisted of BS pack replacement and local compressive pack soaked in antifibrinolytic drug.
In group MC (mean INR 2.59 ± 0.54, mean quick test 27.8% ± 8.6), 10 postoperative bleeding complications were observed (12.5%) (mean INR 2.6 ± 0.57). Three bleeding complications were observed during the first 24 h, six during the second postoperative day, and one during the 3rd day. Three bleeding complications occurred in the maxilla and seven in the mandible; four were in anterior teeth and six in posterior teeth. The etiologies of extraction were caries in six patients and periodontal disease in four patients. Three bleeding complications were controlled through local pressure with gauze soaked in antifibrinolytic for 3 h, and seven complications were controlled through wound curettage and replacement of a hemostatic plug and suture.
None of the mediate postoperative bleeding required hospitalization, blood transfusion or any further local clinical maneuvers to stop the bleeding. No thromboembolic complication or infectious endocarditis was observed.
INR and quick test values did not differ statistically among groups (P > 0.05). Postoperative bleeding complication in groups SB and FTA differed statistically (P < 0.05) from group MC, which presented significantly more bleeding complications.
| Discussion|| |
Patients under chronic oral anticoagulant therapy who require dental extraction pose a problem for dental surgeons because there is no international consensus for their surgical management. Conventionally, the anticoagulant therapy was either suppressed from 2 to 6 days before surgery or the dose of the anticoagulant was reduced to obtain sub-therapeutic levels in plasma, or even replaced by heparin., These protocols have changed, mainly due to the fact that they often require hospitalization and even worse, because of the enhanced risk of thromboembolism. In recent years, the continuation of the oral anticoagulant regime during the course of oral surgery procedures has gained more attention in the literature, which emphasizes the role of local hemostasis.,,, Several local hemostatic agents have been used after tooth extractions in patients under sustained anticoagulation therapy;,,, however, no data exist in the literature on the clinical use of BS as a local anticoagulant agent for the use in dental extractions.
FTA (also referred to as fibrin glue or fibrin sealant adhesive) is composed of fibrinogen, thrombin, factor XIII and anti-fibrinolytics, including aprotinin or tranexamic acid. When these components are combined, they mimic the final stages of the physiological process that cleaves fibrinogen and transforms it into fibrin polymers under the action of thrombin. Factor XIII, activated by thrombin in the presence of Ca2+, cross-links the fibrin polymers into a stable, insoluble fibrin clot. For patients treated with FTA, some studies report bleeding incidence in approximately 4%,, while another reports 8.7%. In the current study, bleeding incidence was 1.25%, as only one patient presented bleeding 24 h after the surgery. The disadvantages of FTA are the possibility of an anaphylactic reaction or the onset of acquired bleeding diathesis secondary to exposure to bovine factor V. These complications were not observed in the present study. Furthermore, its high price considerably increases the cost of dental extraction.
MC (or textured collagen), either porcine or bovine, has a reticular arrangement that enables the entrapment and subsequent aggregation of circulating platelets, activation of coagulation factor XII (Hageman Factor), and stabilization of fibrin filaments. Moreover, the micro fibrils swell in contact with the water fraction of blood, thus adhering to the affected area and creating effective vascular cement that physically obstructs the capillary vessels, decreasing postoperative pain and improving the clinical aspects of the wound. Bublitz et al. have reported 19% incidence of postoperative bleeding in patients under an anticoagulant regime treated locally with MC, and similar incidence was observed in the present study, at 12.5%.
Another commonly used antifibrinolytic drug is tranexamic acid, which is a synthetic derivative of lysine that reversibly binds to lysine receptors on plasminogen and plasmin molecules, thus interfering with the fibrinolytic process. Some studies have demonstrated its effectiveness in the control of postoperative bleeding when used in the form of mouthwash.,
BS is an insoluble compound that has been extensively used in the past in the treatment of a range of disorders such as Vincent's angina and syphilis, reducing colostomy odor, and cleaning open wounds. BS has hemostatic properties, acting on coagulation factor XII (Hageman factor), thus leading to the activation of the coagulation cascade and improving early formation of the fibrin clot. It behaves as a light astringent, precipitating vascular proteins that may obliterate the small capillary vessels. Previous studies in rats showed that BS does not interfere with the wound-healing process, or postextraction bone healing. Good hemostasis has been achieved by using the drug as local hemostatic in tonsillectomy and in dentistry as topical hemostatic agent at palatal donor sites. One of its main advantages, particularly in underdeveloped or developing countries, is its low cost. BS appears to be as effective as FTA in preventing postextraction hemorrhage. Both BS and FTA are more effective than MC for controlling postoperative bleeding in anticoagulated patients, as the results of this clinical trial have shown. BS could be considered an alternative to FTA as a local anticoagulant agent for the prevention of bleeding complication after simple dental extractions in orally anticoagulated patients.
In cases of multiple dental extractions, it is prudent to realize single tooth extraction surgeries, to reduce the chances of bleeding complications. The single postoperative bleeding complication in FTA group observed in this study corresponded after the extraction of four teeth in the same surgery.
Our findings support previously published studies in that severe postoperative hemorrhage does not generally constitute a problem after dental extraction in patients receiving anticoagulant drugs, and who are treated under local analgesia on an outpatient basis with local maneuvers., Simple dental extractions in orally anticoagulated patients can be performed without interrupting their anticoagulation drug by applying local hemostatic maneuvers. Future researches will explore the influence of INR values on postsurgical bleeding.
| Conclusion|| |
This clinical trial showed significantly lower postoperative bleeding complication when BS or FTA plugs were used than when MC plugs were used.
The authors would like to thank the Journal Section of the School of Dentistry of University of Buenos Aires for assistance with this manuscript.
Financial support and sponsorship
This study was financially supported by the School of Dentistry of the University of Buenos Aires. Grant CD 330. Economic support for materials.
Conflicts of interest
There are no conflicts of interest.
| References|| |
Igelbrink S, Burghardt S, Michel B, Kübler NR, Holtmann H. Secondary bleedings in oral surgery emergency service: A cross-sectional study. Int J Dent 2018;2018:6595406 p6.
Cocero N, Mozzati M, Ambrogio M, Bisi M, Morello M, Bergamasco L. Bleeding rate during oral surgery of oral anticoagulant therapy patients with associated systemic pathologic entities: A prospective study of more than 500 extractions. J Oral Maxillofac Surg 2014;72:858-67.
Yang S, Shi Q, Liu J, Li J, Xu J. Should oral anticoagulant therapy be continued during dental extraction? A meta-analysis. BMC Oral Health 2016;16:81.
Lu SY, Lin LH, Hsue SS. Management of dental extractions in patients on warfarin and antiplatelet therapy. J Formos Med Assoc 2018;117:979-86.
Ehrhard S, Burkhard JP, Exadaktylos AK, Sauter TC. Severe enoral bleeding with a direct oral anticoagulant after tooth extraction and heparin bridging treatment. Case Rep Emerg Med 2019;2019:6208604 p5.
Garcia DA, Regan S, Henault LE, Upadhyay A, Baker J, Othman M, et al
. Risk of thromboembolism with short-term interruption of warfarin therapy. Arch Intern Med 2008;168:63-9.
Weltman NJ, Al-Attar Y, Cheung J, Duncan DP, Katchky A, Azarpazhooh A, et al
. Management of dental extractions in patients taking warfarin as anticoagulant treatment: A systematic review. J Can Dent Assoc 2015;81:f20.
Wilson W, Taubert KA, Gewitz M, Lockhart PB, Baddour LM, Levison M, et al
. Prevention of infective endocarditis: Guidelines from the American Heart Association: A guideline from the American Heart Association Rheumatic Fever, Endocarditis, and Kawasaki Disease Committee, Council on Cardiovascular Disease in the Young, and the Council on Clinical Cardiology, Council on Cardiovascular Surgery and Anesthesia, and the Quality of Care and Outcomes Research Interdisciplinary Working Group. Circulation 2007;116:1736-54.
Bublitz R, Sommer S, Weingart D, Bäuerle K, Both A. Hemostatic wound management in marcumar patients. Collagen fleece vs. tranexamic acid. Mund Kiefer Gesichtschir 2000;4:240-4.
Sierra DH. Fibrin sealant adhesive systems: A review of their chemistry, material properties and clinical applications. J Biomater Appl 1993;7:309-52.
Soares EC, Costa FW, Bezerra TP, Nogueira CB, de Barros Silva PG, Batista SH, et al
. Postoperative hemostatic efficacy of gauze soaked in tranexamic acid, fibrin sponge, and dry gauze compression following dental extractions in anticoagulated patients with cardiovascular disease: A prospective, randomized study. Oral Maxillofac Surg 2015;19:209-16.
Ockerman A, Miclotte I, Vanhaverbeke M, Verhamme P, Poortmans LL, Vanassche T, et al
. Local haemostatic measures after tooth removal in patients on antithrombotic therapy: A systematic review. Clin Oral Investig 2019;23:1695-708.
Halfpenny W, Fraser JS, Adlam DM. Comparison of 2 hemostatic agents for the prevention of postextraction hemorrhage in patients on anticoagulants. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol Endod 2001;92:257-9.
Bodner L, Weinstein JM, Kleiner A. Efficacy of fibrin sealant in patients on varius level of oral anticoagulant undergoing oral surgery. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol Endod 1998;86:421-4.
Carter G, Goss A, Lloyd J, Tocchetti R. Tranexamic acid mouthwash versus autologous fibrin glue in patients taking warfarin undergoing dental extractions: A randomized prospective clinical study. J Oral Maxillofac Surg 2003;61:1432-5.
Tock B, Drohan W, Hess J, Pusateri A, Holcomb J, MacPhee M. Haemophilia and advanced fibrin sealant technologies. Haemophilia 1998;4:449-55.
Shaw N. Textured collagen, a hemostatic agent. A pilot study. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol 1991;72:642-5.
Engelen ET, Schutgens RE, Mauser-Bunschoten EP, van Es RJ, van Galen KP. Antifibrinolytic therapy for preventing oral bleeding in people on anticoagulants undergoing minor oral surgery or dental extractions. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2018;7:CD012293
Tramontina VA, Machado MA, Nogueira Filho Gda R, Kim SH, Vizzioli MR, Toledo Sd. Effect of bismuth subgallate (local hemostatic agent) on wound healing in rats. Histological and histometric findings. Braz Dent J 2002;13:11-6.
Santos RM, Sampaio CP, Moraes DP, Lima RL. Evaluation of the effects of bismuth subgallate on wound healing in rats. Histological findings. Int Arch Otorhinolaryngol 2016;20:377-81.
Puia SA, Renou SJ, Rey EA, Guglielmotti MB, Bozzini CE. Effect of bismuth subgallate (a hemostatic agent) on bone repair; a histologic, radiographic and histomorphometric study in rats. Int J Oral Maxillofac Surg 2009;38:785-9.
Fenton JE, Blayney AW, O'Dwyer TP. Bismuth subgallate – Its role in tonsillectomy. J Laryngol Otol 1995;109:203-5.
Kim SH, Tramontina VA, Papalexiou V, Luczyszyn SM. Bismuth subgallate as a topical hemostatic agent at palatal donor sites. Quintessence Int 2010;41:645-9.
Dudek D, Marchionni S, Gabriele M, Iurlaro A, Helewski K, Toti P, et al
. Bleeding rate after tooth extraction in patients under oral anticoagulant therapy. J Craniofac Surg 2016;27:1228-33.
[Figure 1], [Figure 2], [Figure 3]
[Table 1], [Table 2]